on falling in love with baseball boy By Emily Yoon
Garden Party Magazine Issue 3 - Rituals
13 July 2026
I’d consider myself well-acquainted with the ritual and routine of crushing.
I was never a particularly outgoing person when it came to following through on a crush. I was more like a rock waiting for the ocean to swim to me. I stayed very still, but inside, I revelled in the joy and the squirm of it all: thinking about someone, replaying the small, limited interactions we’d had.
When Emily sent me “on falling in love with baseball boy,” I was reverted straight back to those feelings ( and anxieties) of slowly and dangerously falling for someone you just knew was no good for you. But god, wasn’t it fun? For a second, to indulge in the way they made you feel, exactly as they intended? To be at the mercy of a slight arm brush, a squeeze past you in a doorway, a glance and the flicker of a smirk. For him to run off with his friends and leave you sitting there, still glowing in the bubble of his effect.
The late nights spent mulling over every interaction, replaying it, embellishing it, building whole imagined futures out of nothing. The extra ten minutes spent getting ready. All for one look, one “hey”, a conversation - small proofs that you’d been noticed and permission for our mind to continue to get ahead of itself.
Now I’m in a happy, committed relationship, and my fiancé gives me all of the schoolgirl blushing with none of the trauma and mind games that used to come attached to it.
But when I read Emily’s short poem which attunes to and honours this exact sensation, I couldn’t help but reach back and hug that time in my life, when my heart and my mind knew no separation. When I stepped into a crush as innocently and giddily as every girl should get to, at least once.
Happy falling,
Elena xx
on falling in love with baseball boy
Oh, but don’t you remember when baseball boy asked you to ride in his car with him?
Pearly-white teeth & talking in that casual tone-of-voice that only pretty boys seem to have mastered, about his new whip and Paul McCartney and shirtless bonfire nights with the crew. International news and a looming future are but a blip to him, and maybe that’s what makes him so beautiful. The world through the green eyes of he who it’s crafted for, after all, is most lovely. And my dear, I suppose it’s okay to revel in baseball boy’s winks and sunny-warm embrace and the way he calls your name, just this once.
on falling in love with baseball boy
Emily Yoon
@emyoonn
Substack handle:
“I wrote “on falling in love with baseball boy” when I was 17. I had no idea when writing this poem that it would still be dear to me now, five years later. But it is! There’s something so timeless and equalizing about how silly you become, and how consequential every moment feels, when you’ve got a crush.”
Emily Yoon is a recent graduate of UC Santa Barbara (B.A. in English) and a proud California native. She loves to write stories and personal essays that document the whimsy in the ordinary. Emily is a staunch believer in taking too many candid photos of your friends and family, committing to the bit, and betting on yourself.
PRE-ORDER ISSUE 03 NOW and recieve a limited free print from the issue with each order. SHOP ISSUE 03
Conversation
Loading comments…